I had a very good conversation with Steve Brendtro of "We are Perdido" last week on my Coffee with the Commissioner event Wednesday. (Starting at 19:29 of this video)
I had a lot of folks watch and comment and I tried my best to be neutral while at the same time asking Devil's Advocate type questions.
My official position: I am neutral on this Perdido City Incorporation initiative, because although it is in my district-- I believe the citizens have the right to make this decision without my thumb on the scale. And as I said during my coffee meeting--if such an initiative goes through-it actually makes my job easier as many of the headaches and legacy traffic and other issues could be passed along to the new city. IF the new city wants to take them.
Which brought me to the seminal question of the interview Wednesday: What particular problem is incorporation looking to solve? If the new Perdido City will keep the county's existing fire service, schools, sheriff's department, code enforcement, parks, beach access points, code of ordinances and will NOT take over Perdido Key Drive or Innerarity Road along with Bauer Road from the County---then what problem is incorporation solving?
The answer was opaque, byzantine and nebulous at best, feel-good and subjective at worst as I look back on the interview and study the responses carefully.
I think folks would support paying new taxes on their utility bills, new and higher business taxes and fees, and the big Kahuna of it all --two or three new mills on top of the existing property tax bill------if there was going to be new police coverage, new fire services, a new planning department, a new parks department, road and drainage engineering staff, etc. But I'm hearing none of this is part of the plan.
So if not-- again an important question must be answered which is this---what problem is this solving?
Now, in the wake of the interview, several have facebook messaged me that they are "blocked" from the "We are Perdido" facebook site and some comments are hidden and others are not being allowed to post.
I know, better than most, that social media can be a toxic gutter of trolls,fakes, wannabes, losers and bullies. That's the arena in which we live today, and you have to have thick skin and a titanium backbone to play in it. And you have to ignore the garbage spewers and haters. Most of them have empty lives and are simply attempting projection.
So yes---- you have to strap on your armor and take it -----you can't just censor it----or else people feel they are being misled or deceived which is not good when citizens are being asked to get behind a new and expanded government model which will cost potentially millions of dollars in new taxes and fees on top of the existing tax burdens they carry already.
A former commissioner knows this very well as he is currently in litigation over such conduct while he was in office and he might potentially face huge legal fees as a result--in addition to ethics charges, huge state ethics board fines, and all kinds of horrible press.
Now, We are Perdido is a private group so they may not necessarily have to be fully transparent on social media like elected officials are supposed to be. But if they aren't transparent---the optics are bad.
So I went and looked at the We are Perdido Facebook site and indeed it does appear as if several posts indicate multiple comments while only one or two such comments are visible. This is a problem.
If you want to be neutral and unbiased, you can't engage in viewpoint discrimination by blocking folks, hiding citizen feedback, and stifling dissent.
Very poor form.