Guidelines

I have established this blog as a means of transparency to the public, outreach to the community, and information dissemination to all who choose to look. Feedback is welcome, but because public participation is equally encouraged, appropriate language and decorum is mandatory.

Saturday, March 28, 2015

The Shadow Economy, Part I



District Booster clubs, PTA's  and other Outside Support Organizations (OSO's)  provide support and assistance to students and athletic programs throughout our district.

We fully support and embrace the assistance provided by these groups.  In many instances we could not pay to staff the activities that these volunteers provide for our students.

But one area that has not been fully addressed is the level of oversight of these organizations, particularly when students and parents at some district schools are directed to pay athletic or other fees directly to these organizations in order for their students to participate in sports or other extracurricular activities.

In a soon to be released report on this subject, the district's internal auditing department makes some really good suggestions to improve the district's process for oversight/accountability of these organizations.  from the soon to be released report:



"we collected annual financial information related to each OSO operating in the District. We noted a total of approximately $2.81 million in income and approximately $2.77 million in expenses flowed through the District for the 2013-2014 fiscal year. Approximately $795,000 of income flowed through PTAs and $2.02 million flowed through booster clubs..After obtaining all of the information, we tested to determine compliance with District, state, and federal requirements prescribed to OSOs. We also requested and compiled information related to the financial operations of each OSO. District monitoring guidelines mandate that this information be gathered and maintained by school principals. In most instances, principals were unable to provide the information. As such, we were significantly delayed as principals gathered the information from the OSOs. After receiving the required documents, we analyzed this information to determine the approximate amount of resources flowing into and out of the District’s OSOs.. The District has acknowledged that it has some monitoring responsibilities for OSOs, but it appears that  the traditional approach of having principals (or their designees) monitor OSO compliance has not produced the desired results. Many principals did not have the required information from the prior year, and are often unaware of the officers and/or activity of the OSOs they are charged with monitoring We have encountered this same scenario in previous OSO reviews. Although the Office of Community Involvement has some interaction with District PTAs, currently there is no District-level oversight of OSOs. As such, we recommend the District consider centralizing certain duties to adequately monitoring OSOs and help ensure the compliance of OSOs with prescribed District policies and procedures"

I intend to publish this report when it is finalized, as currently it is in draft form.

FASA Drops out of FSBA, Union Lawsuit against School Choice.



This Fantastic news was reported late yesterday in numerous media outlets, and I think this is a good start.

The rest of the groups that are pushing this suit in court should re-evaluate their positions and consider following the lead of FASA.

If we truly care about EVERY child and want to speak with ONE voice, then we need to all be pulling from the same side of the rope, supporting ALL children, in public, private, virtual, and alternative learning environments--and we ought to support the choices parents make about what sort of learning environment is best for each child.

If we want to proclaim we are the voice of education since 1930 then we ought to join everyone here in the 21st century ---and read the polling data that clearly demonstrates that the majority of Floridians support school choice!

It should always be about students, parents, and  tax-payers FIRST--not adult economic interests!

From an article in yesterday's  RedefinED :

"One of the original groups that signed on to the lawsuit last August challenging Florida’s tax credit scholarship program has announced it will no longer be a party to the case.  The Florida Association of School Administrators announced its decision to withdraw in a statement posted on its website and first reported by the Gradebook.
'Having made our position clear with regards to tax credit scholarships through our participation in the lawsuit thus far, it is time to dedicate the resources of our 5,000 members on the priorities that are the heart of our organization.'
Reached by phone, the group’s executive director, Juhan Mixon, said the organization’s “core mission” is to provide professional development to school officials around the state, and that litigation is “not our thing.”  “Our main priorities are teaching and learning,” he said, and the organization’s board, which oversees training for thousands of principals and other school officials, as well as a major digital learning initiative, decided it would be best not “to take resources of our association away from our priority.”

Friday, March 27, 2015

Allegations of Misconduct Part 2: Administrators Told Teachers to Change Grades



....in order to help achieve an "A" letter grade and the resulting school recognition award money from the state.

That is the allegation that irritates me the most.  Another source close to this program has now reached out to me with issues about this school.  The news is not good.

By contrast--other schools, teachers, and staff members worked hard and earned this state bonus money legitimately,

Whereas this one school, allegedly, conspired to fix the grades and usurp the normal, legitimate process for receiving award money from the state.

...and then, to top this off, this organization's director was invited to the ceremony with the Governor last week-- honoring the legitimate work of 21 other district schools that got their recognition money the old fashioned way, they earned it!

from just a small sample of the information I have received:

"XXXX was asked by XXXXXXX to give Senior XXXXXX and Senior XXXXXXXXXX “A”’s in her class. XXXX was asked to delete zeros from missing work assignments the students did not turn in months earlier. XXXXXXXXXX discussed this issue with XXXXXXXXX since they are both new teachers. Both teachers were very upset about the possibility of loosing their jobs and their teaching credentials. XXXXXXXXXX was in tears. XXXXXXXXX  was very upset and told XXXXXXXX.   XXXXXXX encouraged XXXXXXXX to talk to XXXXXXXX about both of them going to the school district and reporting the incident. Neither woman did so. XXXXXXXXXXXXXX heard about teachers being asked to falsify grades for students. XXXXXXXXX asked XXXXXXXXXXX what grade she should give to XXXXXXXXXXX so he would graduate? XXXXXXXXXX was told what grade to issue for XXXXXXXX and she did. XXXXXXXXX was asked by XXXXXXXX and XXXXXXXX to give Senior XXXXXXXXX an “A.” XXXXXXXXX explained to XXXXXXX that XXXXXXXX rarely came to her class and when he did, he did not do his class work. XXXXXX was then asked to gave XXXXXXXXXX a “B” because that was what he needed to graduate. XXXXXXXXXXX was asked to help XXXXXXXXXXX pass his final exam. XXXXXXXXXXXX came to XXXXXXXXXXX classroom. XXXXXXXX allowed XXXXXXXXX to take his final exam. XXXXXXXXXX give XXXXXX the answers to the exam by standing over XXX shoulder and reciting them out loud because XXXXXX did not know the material. "


Thursday, March 26, 2015

Allegations of Misconduct Part 1: Falsifying Student Records to Obtain School Recognition Award Money



The worst example a public charter school can set is cheating.

Cheating to boost graduation rates, which ultimately raises school letter grades, that ultimately assists a school in receiving funds from the state for bonuses--is about the worst example any school could set.

There are allegations against one of our charter schools that are brewing to a roiling boil today, and I reiterate that at this point they are just that---allegations---of widespread grade tampering.

However, the evidence that continues to come in to me on this matter is enough for me to start asking some tough questions---which I have done and which I will continue to do.

From just a small part of what I have received on this matter:


"Many teachers changed grades, deleted zeros, deleted overdue assignments, forged passing grades, combined assignments, gave answers to tests, allowed additional time for over due assignments to be turned in, and falsified attendance records because it was asked of them in order to pass XXXXXXXXXXXXXX  Seniors onto graduation so the school could maintain its “A” rating..XXXXXXX XXXXXXXXXXXX was seen by several people telling senior XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX the answers to online class work in the front office using the computer closest to the office door near the girl’s bathroom after school on May 28th.  One parent (XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX) of a graduating senior (XXXXXXXXXXXX) called XXXXXX XXXXXXXX to 

Devastating Allegations Swirl around One District Charter School Program



Last night I received a phone call at 7:45.  The conversation lasted more than an hour, and the allegations were stomach churning.   The allegations are so numerous and simply so outlandish, that the pages of documentation sent to me have already been sent to our Attorney and to the Superintendent.

Sadly, I have already been able to independently confirm that some of these allegations are true.

To say I'm disappointed in what I'm reading is the understatement of the decade.

More importantly than this damning information, is the lack of knowledge about it.  The board, me and my counterparts, so far as I know, were totally left in the dark on the most severe transgressions alleged in these documents.

I'm sitting in meetings as recently as last month, glowingly praising this program----blissfully unaware that MAJOR allegations have been leveled against this program for more that a year.  Documents and phone records prove this out.

These documents, which I have turned over to Legal, show a pattern of misbehavior that could potentially result in criminal charges;  these allegations, if true, will lead to the end of careers.

Tuesday, March 24, 2015

School Choice Support Email and My Response















From:


























XXXXXXXXXXXXX    Tuesday - March 24, 2015 

Subject:
Note of Gratitude
Attachments:

Good morning, Mr. Bergosh. 

While meeting with Ms. XXXXXXXX of XXXXXXXXXXX last week, I learned of your support for the Step Up for Students program in our county. As both an administrator at a private Christian school and a XXXXXX of four little ones, I would like to express my gratitude to you for your support for this important and unique program. 
I know first-hand the difference that these funds is making in the lives of families in our county by providing them with educational choices that they would not otherwise be able to afford. 
We appreciate you. 
Cordially, 

XXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Director of Development


My response:




From:
JeffreyBergosh Tuesday - March 24, 2015 



To:
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Subject:
Re: Note of Gratitude

Thank you very much XXXXXXXXXX.


I am a big proponent of choice in education---and I strongly believe that providing parents and students a wide array of choice and customization in education is the recipe for reviving a robust, efficient, and effective public school system in America.

The wrong way to go about building up and improving public education is precisely what we appear to be doing--which is attempting to kill anything short of a complete, 100% monopoly favoring, exclusively, public schools for the provision of educational services.

This is the wrong track to be on and that is why I remain so vocal on this.  This mentality puts big labor, special interests, and adult economic matters ahead of students, parents, and taxpayers.

I appreciate what you do for students, and unlike my counterparts, I appreciate, respect, and fully support the right of parents to take advantage of tax-credit scholarships when they feel this is in the best interest of their children, and that's why I support Florida's tax credit scholarship program;  in many instances we've simply failed to provide what all our students need and unlike my counterparts I also know this is not always just a "give us more time and resources for the public schools and we will fix them" issue.  Sometimes students and parents just need an alternative setting for their students, and we ought not to, as public school leaders, get in the way of parental choice.

Parental choice is ultimately what will save our public schools.  I simply wish more people could see and understand this simple axiom of truth.

Have a great week!


Respectfully,

Jeff Bergosh



Monday, March 23, 2015

#NSBAConference 2015 Nashville-Day 3--VPK, Distance Learning in Alaska, and Montel Williams.


Day three of the NSBA conference for 2015 began with a break out session on the value of VPK programs-- presented by officials from Pennsylvania that are intimately involved with VPK in that state.  I must admit that I attended this session with an open mind, however I remain skeptical as to the educational benefits, long term, that these programs impart. Nancy Fishman, the director of Pennsylvania's Early Learning Investment Coalition, and Kathy Swope, the 2015 President-Elect of the Pennsylvania School Boards Association, led the panel.  The presentation began with graphics illustrating that the human brain develops the majority of its simplest, yet most important "circuits" early in life, with sensory pathways, language, and higher cognitive functions developing in the first five years.  The group described the educational benefits of ECE based upon results gleaned from the Perry/Highscope project from the 1960's.  Several other studies were mentioned, but no one specific study was listed as the proof that investment in ECE increases graduation rates.  A couple of interesting survey responses were presented in this session, although the value of this information does not really pertain to the efficacy of ECE programs so far as I can tell.  Statistic One:  93% of more than 300 employees surveyed agreed that a candidate's demonstrated soft skills (extensive list here) are more important than their undergraduate degree of study.  Statistic two:  56% of 1000 middle schoolers would rather eat broccoli than do math homework?  Also stated at the conference without any studies supporting the claim was that larger investments in ECE reduce a school district's ESE spending.  Interesting tidbit that I will look into and research.  At the end of the study I asked the panel to explain where the proof of ECE's long lasting educational impacts could be found and I asked their thoughts on the recent Vanderbilt Peabody study and the Head-Start study that appeared to both show no lasting long-term academic benefit from these programs.  The panel said that they believe the head start study had design flaws.  Needless to say, I'm still skeptical.  I believe these programs are beneficial socially, economically, and that these programs may ease transition into school for students--however I take issue with the huge amounts of taxpayer cash being fed to these programs under the guise that these programs result in higher graduation rates.  I have seen no compelling proof of this from well constructed research.

The next presentation I attended was a discussion of distance learning presented by members of the Lower Kuskokwim School District  (LKSD)from Bethel, Alaska.  This district's story is compelling.  This district is in a part of Alaska that has no roads--most all transportation takes place by air, boat, or snow machine.  The district has 4,100 students spread out in small towns and Native Alaskan Villages in a massive geographical area of 21,000 square miles--roughly the same size of the entire state of West Virginia!  To ensure all students in this district receive a world-class education, the district has invested in an extensive wireless network that links all of the school sites via computer.  The cost of the wireless network in an astonishingly huge $23 Million yearly--however the superintendent reported that the majority of this cost is met by federal and state grants.  Many of the students receive their education remotely via Video Tele-Conferencing (VTC)--which solves what would otherwise be a daunting transportation challenge. This district has made huge strides in technology; to put this district's massive move toward technology into perspective, the presenters note that as late as 1979--there was but one (1) phone in the entire town of Bethel, the main city in this district. People from around the whole area would have to line up at city hall to take "turns" using the phone.  Nowadays,  students in LKSD have many teachers that remote in from Alaska and also from as far away as Wisconsin.  The technology allows students in this remote part of the world to access the resources necessary to receive a world class education--and this district has fielded championship robotics teams three years running--teams that have competed in the world robotics challenge.  Interestingly, this district's students are utilizing technology today that is literally on the cutting edge--technology that in many respects points to the future of education for many students in our nation that live in remote areas.


The final presentation of the day was a fiery, inspirational appearance by television personality Montel Williams.  He came to NSBA's final general session with an up-beat, positive message for the assembled school board members.  Before he even started his presentation, he led the audience in a series of exercises to "Wake the crowd up" he stated.  He walked around the room for most of his presentation, rarely getting up on the stage.  He talked a lot about his own journey in life and his early days in public schools, and some of his challenges and many of his successes.  He thanked the crowd for what they do for enhancing American education, proudly exclaiming to the crowd "Do you know that our graduation rates in America today are at 82%, and this is an all-time high!"  he continued "We hear a lot about this country doing this or beating us by three points on this test or that metric---but let me tell you what, Who Cares! I mean, when was the last time Finland or Sweden produced  a start-up company that anyone has heard of?!? We live in America, the greatest country in the World" said Williams to enthusiastic applause.  He next talked about his military service, and his enlistment in the U. S. Marine Corps where he excelled and was invited to attend the Naval Academy and was the only African-American selectee among the 40 who were chosen for this honor.  Eventually, he was but one of 4 that completed their education in the Naval Academy from this original group of 40.  Williams earned his degree in Engineering, attended the Defense Language Institute in Monterrey, California where he learned to speak Russian.  He ended up serving the country for 22 years in the Marines.  After his service, he began a successful career in television broadcasting, with a 17 year run doing "The Montel Williams Show"  His message to the group was to keep working hard to make the public schools as good as they can be, and he imparted his no excuses mantra to the audience>, stating "It does not matter where you come from, what your family looks like, what your level of support is--none of that matters as long as you are supported with a strong public school--you can succeed in America!"