Guidelines

I have established this blog as a means of transparency to the public, outreach to the community, and information dissemination to all who choose to look. Feedback is welcome, but because public participation is equally encouraged, appropriate language and decorum is mandatory.
Showing posts with label property insurance rates. Show all posts
Showing posts with label property insurance rates. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 18, 2023

Can Something More Be Done on Property Insurance?

Folks that think we should "wait" to do more on property insurance in Florida are living in an alternate reality.....constituents I represent that are getting squeezed want action THIS SESSION!

Tomorrow morning the Board of County Commissioners will once again be discussing legislative priorities, ahead of the upcoming Legislative session beginning early next year.

 At our last meeting we discussed this as well.

 Some things that may bubble up to the surface: 

 --fixing the disastrous "live local act" that completely preempts local control and zoning for large apartment buildings--allowing owners to bypass counties and municipalities and dump huge developments in any commercial or industrial zoned property.

 --Getting the Beulah Interchange funded and in the five year work plan for construction.  This is a MUST do.

 --fixing the reimbursement problem for federal and state prisoners who spend months and sometimes years in our county jail and for which we get no reimbursement--costing local taxpayers precious local tax dollars that should be shouldered by the State and/or Federal Government.

 and there are others as well.

 But one HUGE one that we are all living and we are all hearing about is our broken, dysfunctional property insurance market here in Florida.

 Last year's legislation did not do anything to ease costs and non-renewals yet.  This is a TOP issue I am hearing about from the county residents I represent.

 As I said in an interview on Monday with Rick Outzen, I don't know how preventing homeowners from suing their insurance company benefits anyone other than insurance companies.  I'm told a legislative scheme to force the insurers to share the savings with policyholders was baked into the legislation, which is good.  But can't more be done this year, too?

My idea is pretty simple.   Exercise the power of the legislature to compel those companies that make a literal FORTUNE selling high-priced automobile insurance in Florida (Farmers, USAA, Progressive, State Farm, Allstate, Liberty Mutual, etc.) to also sell property insurance in our state at the same proportional ratio as they do in the average of the other 50 states.  And obviously at a rate that is not simply set at an astronomical number to insure none will be sold--simply to check the box.  Make them and their subsidiaries write the same atuo/property mix as they do in other places at competitive prices.  Now, I am aware there is legislation on the books that mandates the auto policy sellers in Florida also sell property insurance---but there is a loophole that the big auto insurers are utilizing.  One company, in particular, warehouses their property policies in the state and writes these policies through citizen's insurance--which puts you and I, the taxpayers, on the hook!  This company, by the way, then subsequently keeps all their auto policies in their name under their brand. And this allows these insurers to still eat their cake and make nice profits (based upon volume of sale made--due to a 5% profit cap) on auto policies while dumping volatile, less profitable property insurance--thus allowing them to DUMP the Broccoli off of their collective plates.

It has to change.. and at some point the state will have to seriously look at also subsidizing this market,-just like the Federal Government does.  

I understand that the state of florida has what is called the Florida Hurricane Catastrophe Fund - called the Cat Fund. And it has billions in its coffers that we as policyholders have paid when we pay our insurance premiums.  In the 30 years of its existance the cat fund has never spent more than $8 billion and it now has about $15 billion in the bank. Why can't the legislture set aside $2 to $3 billion and let the companies buy this reinsurance cheaper and pass those savings onto us as the policyholders?   Right now 35-40 cents of every dollar of premium is paying for this reinsurance.  A state subsidy here could result in an immediate 15% savings for the policyholders.  So why not do it in this next session!?!

I keep hearing that there is worry the cat fund will run out of money.  That makes no sense…it collects over a $1 billion a year from what I understand--and it has a replenishment mechanism built in to quickly re-fill the fund via policy-holder assessments post-storm----- in the event the fund was to ever become completely depleted----- which, again, has not happened in the last thirty years.

So there are roughly 7.5 million property insurance policies in Florida.  And 6 Million of those are written by Florida companies, which puts Florida firms and ultimately, Floridians, at the greatest risk

By contrast--there are about 12 million auto policies--the majority of which are written by out of state insurers!

So the out of state companies have lower risk and higher profits--where the Florida companies and Citizens shoulder the higher risks.  This needs to be fixed and balanced, period.  The legislature can do this---if they have the will.

We cannot keep telling our constituents that we have to wait two more years for the litigation reforms to take effect.  And I understand that a rate rollback isnt an option because every insurance company would leave.

 I also understand that there are 4 major reasons our rates are so high:  Inflation - we can do nothing about it and I know it costs more to replace and repair homes...

 the severe weather - we can do nothing about that either other than more strict building ordinances and stricter zoning on where housing can be developed--both of which are primarily local issues.

 litigation - The Governor and legislature has done a lot about this and all are saying we will see that it can slow rate increases.... but how long will that take?

 and reinsurance.   We MUST champion making the cat fund more accessible so we can reduce our premiums via providing insurers a cheaper re-insurance option.

 215.555 florida hurricane catastrophe fund, says:

There is a compelling state interest in maintaining a viable and orderly private sector market for property insurance in this state. To the extent that the private sector is unable to maintain a viable and orderly market for property insurance in this state, state actions to maintain such a viable and orderly market are valid and necessary exercises of the police power.

 


Friday, October 28, 2022

Property Insurance Woes Impacting Residents of Escambia County


My property insurance bill just increased by another 25%-- after last year's 100% increase I absorbed.  Others in Escambia County are having it worse and it is not an improving situation.  What can be done?

Should I be thankful?  My property insurance was renewed as of this upcoming 11/22/22 through my current carrier, SLIDE. (A company I had never heard of prior to last year when they took over my coverage due to the dissolution of St. John's Insurance--a company I had been with for the previous 15 years...)

Since 2004, I had St. Johns and the premiums remained reasonable and relatively stable at about $1,400-$1,500 per year.

Last year, however, the premiums jumped 100% to $2,800.  Inexplicably.  I just got a notification that my policy was doubling-----and that is for a homeowner, me, who had ZERO claims in the previous 16 years with the same company.

Ironically, I had my first claim last year for a roof replacement.  I was bracing for the renewal and when I opened it up recently my first thought was "Okay, good, I got renewed!"  lots of folks locally, for a number of various reasons due to tremendous upheaval in the worldwide and nationwide insurance market and re-insurance markets, are being dropped for no specific reason at all provided.  So even though my premium is jumping up another 25% or $700 per year, to $3,500---I guess I should feel lucky?

Others are having even more difficulty than I am in Escambia County:

-One resident with whom I spoke was dropped, inexplicably and without prior notice, 2 days before his scheduled renewal.  He had to literally scramble, get his roof inspected, and was able to work with his agent to find alternative coverage within 48 hours. 

-Another constituent with whom I spoke was threatened with cancellation of coverage unless and until she replaced her 12 year old roof (which was allegedly a "30-year" roof).  The policy she ended up getting after jumping through all the hoops was more than double her previous premium.

-Another individual with whom I have spoken and who owns his small home and property free and clear was given an ASTRONOMICAL renewal figure of $8,000 for his small home.  He chose (like many that own their property free and clear) to forego carrying insurance.  He's hoping for the best and that we don't have another storm.

Obviously this is a state-lvel and to some extent a federal level problem.

But it is affecting county residents and I intend to discuss it at an upcoming meeting with my counterparts.  Perhaps there is more the state legislature can do?  Perhaps they can utilize leverage to insure the insurers are not simply raking in the profits on lucrative and perhaps less costly/risky products like auto insurance policies in Florida--while at the same time scaling back (or eliminating altogether) their property insurance footprint in Florida.  Because if allowed to do so, they will suck up all the insurance policy money that is profitable and eliminate their risk by foisting the volatile costly coverage onto taxpayers (Citizens Insurance).  Should they have to take a proportionate share of the risk on property if they are cleaning up on the lower risk auto in the Sunshine State?  Let's face it, they are doing that and are being allowed to do it.  They are eating the cake and leaving the broccoli on the plate for taxpayers.  That's how I see it.

To illustrate this, perhaps we need to look at their practices and portfolio balance (auto/property) in other states that are not as prone to natural calamities?

Look for the discussion to come.

Thursday, May 12, 2022

I'm Not Voting to Raise Property Tax Rates on Existing Escambia County Taxpaying Property Owners

If you're a taxpaying Escambia County property owner---pay attention to the meeting today.  Watch it closely.......


I've never once voted to approve increased year over year property tax rates on existing Escambia County Taxpaying property owners.  Not once in my 15 years in elected office.  And I'm not about to start now, either.

But this is exactly what staff will be asking us to do later this morning.  

They truly feel there is no choice and that they need 45 more career, paid firefighters and that the ONLY way to pay for this extra cost is to put it onto the back of Escambia County taxpaying property owners via a massive increase in the MSBU or the addition of an extra MSTU.  It's a tax increase they are proposing--make no mistake about it.

But here's why I won't/don't support that. 

Property owners are getting crushed right now with historic property insurance rates if not outright policy cancellation.  They are dealing with unprecedented, 40 year inflation on materials for maintenance and repairs of their properties.  If they are paying for services, they are paying rapidly escalating fees and costs as wage-push inflation is rippling through the economy like a Tsunami and forcing service providing purveyors to raise wages and then by extension, service call fees.  Example:  a one hour (or less) easy-peasy installation of a dishwasher is now officially over $200. (Was $99 or  FREE- included with purchase -just two short years ago).  Bleach for cleaning properties has increased a whopping 400% in the last year.  Yeah, 400%.  Everything is going up for everybody in this crazy inflationary environment (did I mention gas prices doubling, to historic high prices over the last year and a half?)---------so I will not let bureauracrats and staffers make the homeowners shoulder more tax burden as the average homeowner is hurting like never before thanks to fiscal dysfunction coming out of Washington DC. 

So no, I don't think struggling families that have purchased a home, or small mom and pop businesses who own property and who are battling this double-edged sword of inflation and employee wage pressure, should be hit over the head with another increase on their property tax bill.  (remember, they just got hit with a new tax the electorate approved for the Escambia Children's Trust).

There's another way, and a better way.

We have the ability, under Florida Statutes 212.055(8), to ask the electorate to approve the levy of an additional sales tax .5 percent or up to 1 percent for the specific purpose of providing fire service county-wide.  This would also, conveniently, compel us to eliminate the current $125 MSBU from current property owners.  Yes, you heard that right.  It would cut property taxes for Escambia County taxpaying property owners.  That's something I believe we could all support.

Additionally--it will make everyone pay toward the service.  Right now---a LOT of citizens do not pay direct MSBU or property taxes that support the fire service.  Out of state visitors pay nothing toward Fire Coverage and services---this funding source change would positively alter that paradigm and provide for a hefty percentage (potentially as much as 35-40%) of the total sales tax funding to be burdened by out of state visitors or those traversing the interstate who pay for goods and services while travelling through.  Like our LOST penny and like the School Board's half penny sales tax---it generates a consistent revenue stream with much of the revenue coming from non-residents.  It also captures revenue from those who make purchases but who currently pay no property taxes or MSBU for fire---like folks who work for Escambia but live in Pace and pay ZERO toward fire protection where they work.

Now, the naysayers will say it is regressive, and that it hurts poor people.  I'd simply say that for the poor this will be less burdensome than some espouse---as essential basics like groceries are already exempt from all sales taxes.  for other, taxable cash purchases a disadvantaged person might make--the hit of a half-percentage will be de minimus.  (if taxable purchases of $1000 are made monthly--the net effect of the levy of a half penny on that would be $5.00--if $2,000 is spent, it would be $10 additional for a month)  At this point I'd simply point out that if a "poor" individual is spending $1,0000, $2000, or $3000 monthly on retail or non-tax exempt purchases some (many? most?) might question whether or not such an individual is/was really poor?

Nevertheless--we can and will have those conversations when and if it becomes necessary.  And I will ask staff to explore this option and I hope to at least get two additional commissioners' support.

I will not cave in the the reflexive, easiest path of least resistance to simply add more to the MSBU on property owners.  Nope, especially if there is another way to do it better.  And I believe there is.  A tax that everyone pays.  Everyone.