Guidelines

I am one member of a five person board. The opinions I express on this forum are mine only, and do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of the Escambia County Staff, Administrators, Employees, or anyone else associated with Escambia County Florida. I am interested in establishing this blog as a means of additional transparency to the public, outreach to the community, and information dissemination to all who choose to look. Feedback is welcome, but because public participation is equally encouraged, appropriate language and decorum is mandatory. Although this is not my campaign site for re-election--sometimes campaign related information will be discussed, therefore in an abundance of caution I add the following :








Friday, August 20, 2021

The Deposition of William Hopkins



The county's litigation with Matt Selover has concluded.  Matt Selover was treated horribly by some inept, former county employees;  his harrassment complaint was buried, his wages were reduced unfairly, and his due process was severely violated.  The county has now settled the case for $200,000.00 ----and now the depositions and associated documents of the case are a public record.

There have been some unflattering portrayals of this case (and inaccurate, incomplete information as well) in memos from the insurance company's lawyers--leaked to the press and not shared with the BCC when the case was being deliberated by commissioners.  There have been armchair, Monday morning keyboard warrior types spreading a bunch of misinformation about the case on facebook chat sites.  And there have been people lying about the case, the timelines, and the reasons this case was settled.

Because of all the propaganda and noise surrounding this case, and because these transcripts are public records which many have requested, I'll be posting them all here, on this blog, one by one,  so folks can read them for themselves---and make their own judgments about how poorly this former employee was treated.

This transcript, linked below, from former Escambia paramedic William Hopkins-- created a devastating hole in the medical director's purported timeline of the "when" she decided and made it known she would seek to restrict Matt Selover's priviledges and report him to the DOH.  Mr. Hopkins directly contradicted the medical director's assertions that the decision was made to restrict the ability of Selover to remain a paramedic the day of the QA/QI board--April 23rd 2019.  In fact, his testimony appears to back Selover's claim that the Medical Director sought to retaliate against him and only took action against his priviledges AFTER she was made aware of Selover's harrassment complaint against her on May 1st...  from p. 62 of the deposition:

A. All I recall that day was the meeting,

followed by Dr. Edler asking us to write up our review

of how the meeting went and then any kind of

observations that we had and that's all I remember. I

don't really remember what happened after that.

Q. Okay. Did you all in that meeting discuss any

type of reprimand or punishing my client?

MS. GUDAITIS: Object to form.

A. (By the Witness) No.

Q. (By Mr. Talbott) In that meeting, did you

discuss anything about limiting his ability to practice

or do certain procedures?

A. A meeting? No.

Q. During that meeting, did you talk about

reporting him to the Department of Health?

A. At that meeting, no.

Q. At some other time, did you talk about

reporting him to the Department of Health?

A. There was a time when Dr. Edler stated that

she may have to do that based upon what she seen, but it

was more of a statement, not more of a -- a asking us

for permission. She was kind of hemming and hawing

about whether or not to do it, so I don't know, I mean,

obviously, I know what her final answer is today, but at

the time I didn't know what her final answer was.


Our attorney, Matt Shaud, sent the following email indicating this entire transcript is/was a public record.  I have removed the pages as recommended---even though legally this was not necessary to do:

"Commissioner Bergosh:

 Attached please find William Hopkins’ deposition transcript.  It does not appear to be subject to any applicable exemptions, but as Charlie noted below, this transcript also contains testimony regarding a xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx.  Those references are on pages 26-28, 43-44, and 88-90.

 Thank you,

 Matt Shaud

Assistant County Attorney"


Read the transcript here




1 comment:

Anonymous said...

I know the paramedics are probably tired of seeing their names out there, so I hope they know we wish them well and hope they are getting along together in Santa Rosa county.

They can thank Underhill for politicizing public safety in 2019 and making it "global" as the past HR stated. He was trying to make himself out to be the hero.

Disclosing these for the ones who wish to be informed clearly show the county made the correct decision to settle because if this had gone to trial I believe the county would have lost.

So this begs the question, Did Maygarden and Gilley call Marceille on behalf of Edler or SAO and get him to trump up the charges on the others? It is noted Edler wanted Maygarden to be HER witness, during an evaluation. How can that be fair? They didn't hear anything from DOH and thought that would solve the conflict?

Well I don't want to mention names but I will

Kate
Leon

What did they do to deserve that?

Not so sure about the other guy... but seriously

SAO will step over a dead body to file a sunshine violation or arrest a public employee, then get an award.

Go ahead..Let ECW or the Studerville cartoonist blame you for doing the right thing. Some have no credibility and they don't even seem to know it.