 |
| Doug's Underhill's redistricting proposal map he presented last night had numerous, fatal flaws. It died shortly after it was presented--receiving zero support for obvious reasons... |
At last night's second joint County Commission/School Board Meeting-- Commissioner Doug Underhill brought a rendition of what he thought the new district lines should look like between District 1 and District 2 in Escambia County.
It received no play whatsoever among those of us who were there and serious about the work at hand.
Doug's map was ill-conceived--- and a total and complete, unmitigated disaster....
His map (above) had so many flaws that were readily apparent--I'm astonished he even brought if forward. It was not unlike a rocket exploding on the launch pad.
As I discussed with him just a few of the glaring problems (
minute 46:27 of this video) I noticed upon just receiving it 5 minutes before he pitched it to the dais members---he didn't acknowledge any of the serious shortcomings of his proposal. Instead-- he simply doubled down on it, with a steaming, rancid helping of gibberish and gobldygook about "equities" being lost and neighborhoods being separated----while ignoring the fact
his map kept Myrtle Grove carved up like a jigsaw puzzle---not fixing the precinct 99 issue as every other map presented has.
Just a few of the MAJOR flaws with the Underhill map that quickly relegated it to the trash recepticle.
---It left District 1 an astonishing 5,584 citizens short of the ideal district size of 64,381
---It left District 1 even 2,365 citizens short of the required 5% statutory minimum deviation below the ideal size
---It boots a duly-elected ECUA Board member out of her seat for which she won election less than one year ago (which would have, for more than the next three years, served to disenfranchise voters who put this official into office)
---In a complete and total snub to the District 1 School Board Member, Kevin Adams, the Underhill plan would have knocked three schools (Bailey Middle, Helen Caro Elementary, and Blue Angels Elementary) out of District 1 against the wishes of this sitting school board member.
I could go on but why? It was a drammatic fail, it was a feckless attempt at actual gerrymandering, and it died upon arrival at last night's meeting. DOA.
But at least he showed up with something. It just wasn't anything useful to the task at hand. At all.