Guidelines

I have established this blog as a means of transparency to the public, outreach to the community, and information dissemination to all who choose to look. Feedback is welcome, but because public participation is equally encouraged, appropriate language and decorum is mandatory.

Wednesday, February 24, 2021

What About the Judges?

 

I asked rhetorically at our last Commission Meeting:  When will our state's Judges under age 65 be offered COVID-19 Vaccination?

As the efforts to vaccinate the maximum number of citizens nationwide accelerates, some very essential workers are apparently being overlooked.  Of course, everybody knows the most vulnerable citizens, in care homes, immunocompromised, and over 65 years of age needed the shot yesterday.  And locally we are hitting that target, with greater than 50% of the citizens over 65 being inoculated against COVID-19.

But now as I read about the next group of citizens eligiblefor shots—including teachers and some other professions with members over age 50—I still don’t see the state’s Judges listed.

They really have nobody pulling for them. Apparently, nobody is advocating for them.  I certainly don’t speak for them---but I am writing this because I believe there may be a HUGE glaring blind-spot that’s shifting focus away from this essential, yet miniscule, cohort of essential state workers.

Judges.

They get overlooked all the time; folks really don’t think about them.  It is esoteric, what they do and how they do it.  When important ceremonies occur, they don’t get the invite.  When they happen to attend important functions—I have witnessed hosts of such events trip over themselves to recognize every other elected official in attendance in such venues—and NOT recognize judges.  They are oftentimes an afterthought--unless one is summoned to appear before a judge. They’re severely restricted in what they can do socially, what they can say politically, and how they must comport themselves publicly.  Most folks do not realize what a person gives up in terms of privacy and privileges when he/she becomes a Judge.  But that’s a whole different topic.  I would certainly have not known much about judges and what they do had my only brother not become one.  But I do have a unique vantage point though- in that my brother has been a circuit court judge here locally for nearly the last decade and a half.  And we talk frequently.  Multiple times weekly.

So far as I have been told—the 16 judges seated in Escambia County under age 65 have not been offered the shot.  “Well why should they get one?”, folks might question sternly.

Here is an example of why:  Just one, and it is personal.   I am hyper-attenuated to this pandemic as one of my closest, best friends, Brad Crager, died of COVID-19 in January.  He was healthy, yet it took him out after an agonizing 2-week hospitalization out in Southern California.  We worked together when I was in college, we were friends for over 30 years. He was like a brother to me.

Then, last week, my only real brother, Gary,  fell ill.  My only brother.  He got really sick.  Fever, chills, and a high temperature.  He was out of it.  He had not/has not been inoculated for COVID-19.  I was worried.

But looking beyond my own concern for a loved one—this illness and related several days quarantine for the COVID-19 test’s results to come back meant 60 jury trials on his docket had to be cancelled.  Sixty of them.  Attorneys, defendants, witnesses, victims, jurors, and public officials were all delayed.  Attorneys from around the country had to reshuffle their schedules, support staff, security-everyone’s schedule was upended.  What about folks scheduled to appear who took personal leave from their jobs to attend?  Now, they will have to take even more precious, valuable leave for these rescheduled trials.

Prisoners in our jail that may have been released—had to stay in Jail.

How much did this one, minor, three-day delay cost?  Who knows, but it costs a lot.

Thankfully, my brother is fine, he tested negative and he is back on the bench.  Had he been given the

shot—perhaps he could have worked through the symptoms with a reassuring knowledge that it was not COVID-19?  But he hasn’t got the shot-so care and precaution had to be the priority.

While we understand the importance of all the “front-line” grocery workers, firemen, police officers, nurses, and teachers wanting to be inoculated---let’s not forget about judges who are still dealing with the public day in and day out and need vaccination, too.

And ask yourself this:

What would the cost in time, money, and aggravation be if multiple judges simultaneously got sick all around the state—because they were not considered essential enough to get a shot—put at the back of the line behind other professions like 24-year old supermarket shelf-stockers?

Yes, we are all created equal, and we are all equal. 

But when looking at the big picture and pulling back to make key decisions on who gets a shot and when/why—we have to make certain we are making good decisions and not neglecting that narrow slice of folks who keep the justice system moving as quickly as possible.

Make no mistake—when this Pandemic passes, and it will, the vaccination programs will be studied.  Who got the shot, when, why, and how?  Did some folks jump the line due to their power or positions?  Was it the “Titanic Lifeboat” tragedy—where “some” took the lifeboat slot while women and children drowned, or worse yet were clubbed to death as they desperately sought reprieve in a lifeboat and were denied? 

Will that be found to have happened when this COVID-19 vaccination rollout gets a post-mortem examination?  Think.

And while we are all thinking and prioritizing, let’s not forget the lynchpin players in the justice system who cannot speak nor advocate for their own benefit; if they are absent the ramifications will ripple through our state like a cracking, about to shatter windshield of a loaded semi-truck on a crowded freeway hit by a rock.

Metaphorically speaking.

 


24 comments:

Anonymous said...

92219x
92219x Other Justice, Public Order, and Safety Activities Other Community- or Government-based Operations and Essential Functions 1b First Responders

https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/covid-19/categories-essential-workers.html

Anonymous said...

Essential Workers Should be Offered Vaccination in Phase 1b or 1c

Anonymous said...

THE WHO

https://weartv.com/news/coronavirus/un-vaccine-plan-is-underway-but-problems-remain

Anonymous said...

Glad your loved one recovered. Aren't hearings done by Zoom? Did he catch it from his work? Who knows..None my business. Now he has antibodies.

This current National administration rejoined the WHO and their America Last policies will further weaken the country. I personally can't believe Americans were so easily manipulated or ignorant to vote this way but here we are.

One of our elected Senators is trying...
https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/296

Remember how razor thin the win for Scott and DeSantis was..and people still malign Gaetz. It looks like they might rely on the New York Times and Washington Post for info. or memes..

On the other hand conspiracies fearing the vaccine run rampart also..

I hate it but many people had to have the virus affect them personally to recognize the seriousness of this. On the flip side the economy must go on.

One of the problems with the current vaccine is once thawed it has to be given and they will be drug across the coals if any is wasted. I think the more they distribute the more they are justified to receive.

People should be charitable and understanding, Perhaps be an available arm to make sure none is wasted...that's not jumping the line is it? It's stewardship of resources. People need to spend less time on the fault finding and more on educating themselves and others and finding solutions.

Be patient, protect yourself. Be part of the solution, not part of the problem.

Anonymous said...

The roll out of the J $J vaccine is a one dose and doesn't require the deep freeze. It may be approved soon. It looks like the state mandates the CDC and classification of eligibility.

Info here if one follows the links and windows.

https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/covid-19/index.html

Anonymous said...

Looks like the tweets on this site are the most current and concise, sans politics
http://www.floridahealth.gov/

Anonymous said...

FL EMTs can administer, houses of worship can be sites..

From what I can tell when they go to 1C phase the judges are eligible before the general population. It's like a snowball, but what I don't like is yes, some were wasted and they are looking into it, which is good, but don't make it so punitive that people will administered expired dosages to stay out of trouble in the short run.
They had to hold back because of power outages last week.

The sooner we get the seniors done, the sooner we get more vaccines.

Register ahead of time to indicate you are interested, even if ineligible and wait in line. We were called to go to a location we didn't want to go but held out, there is a lot of confusion but there are reasons for needing the appts for now. They have to justify the shipments etc. I think once the vaccines are allowed that don't need the deep freeze it will go smoother and more quickly.

This is not an expert opinion just layman observation.

https://twitter.com/HealthyFla


Jeff Bergosh said...

Anonymous 4:16- My understanding is the civil hearings and trials can be done over Zoom, and also some of the more minor criminal trials. But for the majority of the criminal trials, particularly when the jurors are being picked, the judges are in close proximity to the defendants---some of whom are very sick with significant health issues.

Tom Dannheisser said...

Jeff

As we have discussed, although you have valid points, I do not believe that judges should get special priority on vaccines...and I'm the only local judge who is 65.

Tom

Anonymous said...

https://www.tampabay.com/news/health/2021/02/23/who-gets-vaccinated-next-floridas-the-only-state-that-doesnt-tell-you/

Anonymous said...

This blog piqued my interest. Thank you for sharing.

I found this to be good info.

https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2021/01/28/960901166/how-is-the-covid-19-vaccination-campaign-going-in-your-state

The one above is updated regularly.

click back to the link to the KFF page, It is from January
but still useful for statistics and comparisons.
https://www.kff.org/policy-watch/the-covid-19-vaccine-priority-line-continues-to-change-as-states-make-further-updates/

I've come across a few articles that judges in another state got it and thought they were doing the right thing, but others complained. look at the chart on the the efficiencies and garner from that what it means. It looks like some are wasted approx 20-30%. That is probably because of no shows. After they thaw a vial it has to be used or discarded.

Different states have the authority to designate the rollout and as usual some are politicizing it. FL AG and Governor back and forth as usual. It happens. Some groups are whining that NAACP is putting it in over every one and other group whining the rich people are getting it.

Just like kids fighting over the last piece of candy. I'm happy they demand is high and people are clambering to get it.

Actually it looks like the 1C is classified as an essential worker in the Federal AICP guidelines and Florida hasn't been crystal clear.

It looks like obese people and smokers are now eligible, including people with other conditions. Chose your poison. Get in line. It looks like some eligibility overlaps.

imo

Kevin said...

Commissioner Bergosh, how about focusing on a purview you can do something about? Seriously. I would love to see some ounce of concern for County staff who care about covid, and the public forced to interact with them, in the unsafe environment of County buildings.

Yesterday we felt compelled to attend a pre-app on a development project in Navy Point. Of course they always hold those in an undersized conference room, because they want to dissuade the public from attending anyway.

We hadn't attended anything at the Central Complex since covid broke out. So I was surprised to find the hallway locked. Then started the Escambia Covid Theater, as if the doors were locked because they were trying to limit the number of people due to covid concerns.

I mean, TSA got nothing on Escambia administration. To be clear, I am not faulting any of the reception staff at the Central Complex, who are some of the nicest people at the County--they can't do anything about your County administrator being a first-rate covid denier from the get-go. So they do their best under these ridiculous shows of fake management to act as if they have any idea why the hell they are even being asked to do certain things, which Gilley has clearly orchestrated to make everybody as uncomfortable as possible, while serving zero purpose towards the actual management of covid spread. After all that, everybody just piled into the same tiny room as always, with the main chambers available for use right across the hall, where the people who don't spend their days coveting the idea that covid is a fake "plandemic" could properly distance and stay further away from the half dozen County staff who weren't wearing any masks crowded into the cramped pre-app room. Ridiculous.

So while it pains me to be at odds with you on this, I gotta say how I feel. You have had it in your power as commissioner to have a real impact on covid management at the County--and did nothing. You pulled ER docs out of their rounds to do a Commissioner Coffee and ask their recommendations, and they took the time to plead with you to advocate for proper measures and mask wearing in our County--and you did nothing.

So while I do agree with you that there is an unfair incongruity in our court system between civil and criminal courts right now, and also believe that if we are going to hold in person criminal cases, NOT JUST JUDGES BUT JURORS, LAWYERS, AND COURT REPORTERS should be offered vaccination, I really hope that if you could back up the clock, you might have done differently for the County, and been more invested in protecting staff and the public in the arena over which you are a policy maker. Because to downplay covid for months on end, and voice skepticism over any mandated measures to stop the spread, but then to suddenly about-face when it comes to vaccination priorities...I'm not gonna lie. I have a really hard time with that.

--Melissa Pino

Jeff Bergosh said...

Tom--I totally respect your opinion. And nobody should be forced to get one. Heck, when I had a recent coffee meeting with all three hospital CEOs locally--it was reported to me that as much as 50% of the front-line health staff said no to the shot and did not take it. That was an amazing statistic to hear. But I do believe Judges that are still interacting with the public on a regular basis and that want the shot should be able to get it/should be prioritized as essential workers----because when/if they fall ill---as illustrated with Gary's illness last week---the economic and other ramifications are wide-reaching. And particularly if we are going to start reaching out and categorizing the 25 year old shelf-stockers as essential and eligible and NOT judges---I think this would be ridiculous.

Kevin said...

Commissioner Bergosh, that fifty percent statistic on healthcare was provided to you by Florida DOH--hardly the most trustworthy source for covid data, as you yourself have made clear many times on the dais. That was not a nationwide statistic. Nor was it a study, or anything approaching acceptable data. It was nothing more than a guestimate, which could not be backed up when pressed, and typical of the gaslighting that has been coming out of DOH during this entire pandemic. I would have never thought that our state health department would be hobbled and made moot the way it has been in the last couple of years.

So no, you did not hear "the most amazing statistic." In fact, you didn't hear any statistic at all. You heard the same half baked garbage that DOH has been putting out all along. And if our local healthcare workers really were at fifty percent at that time, what better indication that our policy makers across our governmental and medical agencies had failed this community across the board with their precious trust to make certain the public is well informed about public safety measures.

Again, you were in a position to cut through some of the disinformation. You still are.

Those 25 year old shelf-stockers have been exposed to a heck of a lot more covid than a judge, Jeff. And I would just take a wild guess they don't have nearly the healthcare plan.

-Melissa Pino

Tom Dannheisser said...

Actually the "shelf stockers " come into contact with thousands more than we do, we are fairly isolated...I had norovirus also..but getting sick is part of life

Tom Dannheisser said...

Another Judge can always sit in on a case, the prosecutor and defense attorney can't be substituted

Anonymous said...

Sign up. Encourage EVERYONE to sign up.

I think you will find since the Governor hasn't set hard lines in the sand, the people making the appts will fill in the blanks.

This is not professional advice but hang around and get a late appt if you want to bring someone and rather than throw it away and have to make a waste, they will probably give it, especially if you can keep the complainers and fault finder from gumming up the works..
Git er done.





Anonymous said...

Be the dudes in the truck not the shrew in the car.
https://twitter.com/i/status/1364514072419532801

Anonymous said...



YES there was vaccine hesitancy from health care workers yet it is fading: According to the CDC (note not FDOH)


"But the campaign to immunize health care professionals has hit a snag as a notable number of front-line workers decline the vaccine. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, just 38% of nursing home workers participated in the federally run vaccination campaign for residents and employees of the facilities during its first month. Although those numbers likely have risen in the weeks since, and that tally doesn’t include workers who received a vaccine outside of their workplaces, they illustrate the problem.

A Morning Consult survey conducted in the first week of January found that 23% of health care workers said they would never accept the vaccine. Among unvaccinated employees, 38% said they feared long-term side effects. Health care workers appear somewhat more skeptical compared to the general public. A Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation survey last month found that 13% of Americans said they will never get vaccinated against COVID-19.

But surveys are also showing consistently increasing acceptance of the vaccines since they actually became available, and more than 27 million Americans have gotten at least one dose, so hesitancy may be fading."

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/health-care-workers-covid-19-vaccine-hesitancy

Given how much they stand to gain from a safe vaccine, the fact that many health care workers are reluctant may seem surprising to lay people. Many assume the reticence is an outgrowth of the “anti-vax” movement, or a sign that the vaccines aren’t safe. But the reasons health care workers have declined are complicated and disparate.

Christina Allen, a nurse practitioner from Hyattsville, Maryland, was initially hesitant to get a vaccine because of unanswered questions about the vaccines and the inequities in their distribution, especially in Black and brown communities. Still, she got her first dose of the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine on Jan. 13.

“I knew I would get the vaccine eventually. I never had a distrust in the science behind vaccinations and I understand how impactful vaccinations have been in advancing public health and eradicating some of the most deadly viruses and diseases in history,” Allen said. “Because this is a new and novel virus, there’s so much we still don’t know, and so I think that that also created a slight hesitancy for me.”

Allen feels good about her choice to get the shot, though: “I want to protect myself, and not only myself, but my community and my patients as much as possible. And I feel like I did the right thing ― it wasn’t an easy decision ― because I feel like I’ve given myself and others that much more protection.”

Experts and representatives of health care workers and health care employers are quick to emphasize that these hesitant workers aren’t fools, conspiracy theorists or anti-vaxxers. In many ways, their worries grew from the peculiar circumstances of the coronavirus pandemic.

Some health care workers have developed deep mistrust of their employers and government leaders during the pandemic, after months of fighting for basic needs like masks and other personal protective equipment. They have watched the government bungle so many aspects of the COVID-19 response that when those same authority figures tell them to get vaccinated first, essentially to be guinea pigs for new vaccines, their messages aren’t always well-received.

“Folks are caring through a really challenging crisis and are sort of at a breaking point, and we need to understand that and invest in this workforce,” Matthew Yarnell, president of Harrisburg-based Service Employees International Union Healthcare Pennsylvania, said during a conference last month sponsored by the Kaiser Family Foundation. “We feel like there are some very critical steps that need to happen to build trust for a workforce that’s feeling very distrustful of their government, of their employers.”

Anonymous said...

The judge made WEAR news and there is also a good article "Biden predicts shorter wait times"

Read this editorial
https://weartv.com/news/armstrong-army-strong/loosening-the-covid-19-bureaucracy

Anonymous said...

I reread this and realized Judge Bergosh tested neg for Covid but you were still advocating for the roll out of 1c classifications. I would bet if they signed up and all the seniors that signed up for the D1 Clinic were covered and it was close of business and there was an arm there and leftover vaccines thawed out one would get a shot instead of being disposed of and it is not against the law. Thanks to our Governor and limited government. Will someone gnash teeth. Maybe. Probably. Its easier to get forgiveness than permission and those that are able to navigate the gray areas do well. Now that you have the eyes on you...it may be harder to fly under the radar..

One thing is people are social animals and if they think someone may be getting something ahead of them, they will try to get it for themselves. The more people that get these the better off we all are. Hope your D1 clinic is 100% :)

Anonymous said...

DeSantis left many of the decisions into the areana of the ones distributing the vaccines. Small government, If you do look into this after the fact, I think you will recognize more of his genius and leadership in the long run. One hospital opened it to first come first served and had a fiasco in SF. God helps those that help themselves.

Anonymous said...

https://usafacts.org/visualizations/covid-vaccine-tracker-states/

Anonymous said...

The month of March starts Monday. Just saying....

https://www.orlandosentinel.com/coronavirus/ct-aud-nw-nyt-giant-vaccination-sites-20210227-wzhtxkze5jax3nieghdxr6phb4-story.html


"With the nation’s coronavirus vaccine supply expected to swell over the next few months, states and cities are rushing to open mass vaccination sites capable of injecting thousands of shots a day into the arms of Americans"


The sites are one sign of growing momentum toward vaccinating every willing American adult. Johnson & Johnson’s single-dose vaccine could win emergency approval as soon as this weekend, and both Moderna and Pfizer have promised much larger weekly shipments of vaccines by early spring. In addition to using mass sites, pharmacies, community clinics that serve the poor and mobile vaccination units to play major roles in increasing the vaccination rate.

With only about 9% of adults fully vaccinated to date, the kind of scale mass sites provide may be essential as more and more people become eligible for the vaccines and as more infectious variants of the virus proliferate in the United States.

But while the sites are accelerating vaccination to help meet the current overwhelming demand, there are clear signs they won’t be able to address a different challenge lying ahead: the many Americans who are more difficult to reach and who may be reluctant to get the shots."

"To address problems of access and equity, FEMA is opening many of its new mass sites in low-income, heavily Black and Latino neighborhoods where fear of the vaccine is higher, vaccination rates have been lower and many people lack cars. In addition to its mass sites, Community Health Center, which serves large numbers of poor and uninsured people in clinics around the state, is also planning to send small mobile teams into neighborhoods to extend its vaccination reach."


Keep in mind the geography of Escambia County.. for some a trip to Pensacola is a 100 mile round trip and they don't have vehicles. Maybe the red cross can ride around like ice cream trucks and the national guard can show up in locations where they passed out MREs..

Since you brought this up Commissioner Bergosh and posed the question... You know what they say about volunteering in the military? Thanks for raising your hand. :)